If theatre is indeed a reflection of society and offers insights into the culture of a place and its people, then what does Keegan Theatre’s An Irish Carol reveal? Set in a cozy Dublin pub, playwright Matthew J. Keenan and director Mark A. Rhea craft a vivid portrait of camaraderie, tradition, and redemption, all laced with plenty of cursing, rounds of pints, and the lively banter that perhaps defines Irish pub culture.
Among the many variations of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol gracing local theaters this season, the Scrooge in this rendition is David, a grumpy, cynical, embittered pub owner portrayed with simmering tension by Kevin Adams.
For a production now in its 14th season, the set has developed a wonderfully lived-in authenticity. As both playwright and scenic designer, Matthew J. Keenan crafts a pub brimming with character and charm. From its bric-a-brac décor to the unmissable “Fáilte” sign by the door, the space exudes history and community. A glowing fireplace and carefully strung Christmas lights, enhanced by Dan Martin’s lighting design, create a festive yet intimate atmosphere. The setting invites the audience to feel like part of the pub’s world, right down to its cluttered storage spaces and seasonal decorations.
The storytelling itself, steeped in humor and heartfelt moments, unfolds with the natural rhythm of pub chatter, where talk is paramount and actions are subtle but significant. Taylor Witt as Bartek, the hardworking bartender from Poland, is a standout. He moves purposefully through the space, pouring pints, wiping tables, and keeping the pub in order, but he also spontaneously shows that he can bust a move—a delightful moment of joy. With no professional dialect coach listed, the entire cast does a great job maintaining their self-taught accents for duration of the play.
Veteran actors Kevin Adams and Timothy H. Lynch bring depth and familiarity to their roles, having performed in this annual production since its inception. … David’s eventual redemption is undeniably satisfying.
For first-time viewers like myself, An Irish Carol offers a window into Keegan Theatre’s passion for Irish identity and storytelling. It’s a heartfelt tribute to the roots of its founders and a testament to the company’s dedication to creating authentic, engaging theater that celebrates community and tradition.
